Total Pageviews

Tuesday, 3 May 2011

Final Blog

This is my final blog. The following is my entire report. I have changed some things and fixed any mistakes I have found. Everything here is final.




Does the amount of cocoa solids in chocolate effect it’s melting time?

Purpose
The purpose of this experiment is to determine whether the amount of cocoa solids in chocolate has an effect on it’s melting time. I have chosen this experiment because it seemed interesting and because I was curious about why chocolate melt so easily.

Research
*Proper referencing is located in the bibliography at the end of the report. 
  1. What are the main ingredients of chocolate?
[Cacao are beanlike seeds from which cocoa, cocoa butter and chocolate are made]
Cacao paste: The gooey mass made from crushing and heating the roasted beans. This makes up 45-70% of the bar and it is called many different things: Cacao Liquor, Cacao Mass, Cacao Paste etc. 
Cocoa butter: The flavourless fat squeezed out during "Dutch processing" which creates powdered Cocoa. Extra is added to create the texture of the bars. The flavour and texture can be adjusted this way. More Cocoa Butter means a smoother, creamier, less bitter bar. Less Cocoa Butter means a sharper, dryer, more powdery, more flavourful bar.
The percentage of Cacao of a bar is determined by the amounts of these two products of the Cacao Bean, the fat & the flavour, combined under the official heading Chocolate Solids, or Cacao Solids. One of the main differences in taste and texture between brands of bars is how much of each they use. 
Sugar: This makes up almost all of the non-Cacao portion of the bar.
Optional ingredients include vanilla [most chocolate bars add this spice], and lecithin, most bars have a small percentage of lecithin as an emulsifier. This is a soy product that is added to Cacao to control texture & consistency and to improve solubility in cold liquids, such as milk.
  1. At what temperature does chocolate melt at?
Uncontrolled crystallisation of cocoa butter typically results in crystals of varying size, some or all large enough to be clearly seen with the naked eye. This causes the surface of the chocolate to appear mottled and matte, and causes the chocolate to crumble rather than snap when broken. The uniform sheen and crisp bite of properly processed chocolate are the result of consistently small cocoa butter crystals produced by the tempering process.
The fats in cocoa butter can crystallise in six different forms. The primary purpose of tempering is to assure that only the best form is present. The six different crystal forms have different properties.

Crystal
Melting temp.
Notes
I
17 °C (63 °F)
Soft, crumbly, melts too easily.
II
21 °C (70 °F)
Soft, crumbly, melts too easily.
III
26 °C (79 °F)
Firm, poor snap, melts too easily.
IV
28 °C (82 °F)
Firm, good snap, melts too easily.
V
34 °C (93 °F)
Glossy, firm, best snap, melts near body temperature (37 °C).
VI
36 °C (97 °F)
Hard, takes weeks to form.
Generally ‘good’ chocolate has as many V crystals (look at table above) as possible. Chocolate generally has a melting point just below the human body temperature.
  1. Why does chocolate melt so easily?
Chocolate comes from the cocoa bean, originally grown in South America. The ancient Aztecs and Mayans used it mainly in drinks, and it was introduced to Europe by Christopher Columbus in liquid form. In the 19th century, candy makers learned to combine the fat from the cocoa beans (known as cocoa butter) with sugar and other ingredients.
This led to the first edible solid chocolate candies. Cocoa butter remains the key ingredient in most forms of chocolate today.
Around the start of World War II, manufacturers began to explore ways to slow chocolate's melting process. The U.S. Army asked the Hershey Company to make a chocolate bar that soldiers could carry, even in warm temperatures. Hershey altered the recipe to contain less cocoa butter, and added skim milk and sugar. The resulting bars were used throughout the world, including the tropics.
In general, the more cocoa butter a chocolate contains, the more easily it will melt. According to Spartak, a European candy company, many modern chocolate bars use cocoa butter substitutes. These alternatives have a higher melting point than the human body, resulting in a less messy chocolate experience.
Types of Chocolate
White chocolate
Chocolate made with cocoa butter, sugar, milk, emulsifier, vanilla and sometimes other flavourings. It does not contain any non-fat ingredients from the cacao bean and has therefore an off-white colour. In some countries white chocolate cannot be called 'chocolate' because of the low content of cocoa solids. It has a mild and pleasant flavour and can be used to make Chocolate Mousse, Panna Cotta and other desserts.
Milk chocolate
Sweet chocolate which normally contains 10-20% cocoa solids (which includes cocoa and cocoa butter) and more than 12% milk solids. It is seldom used for baking, except for cookies.
Dark chocolate
Sweetened chocolate with high content of cocoa solids and no or very little milk, it may contain up to 12% milk solids. Dark chocolate can either be sweet, semi-sweet, bittersweet or unsweetened. If a recipe specifies 'dark chocolate' you should first try semi-sweet dark chocolate.
Sweet dark chocolate
Similar to semi-sweet chocolate, it is not always possible to distinguish between the flavour of sweet and semi-sweet chocolate. If a recipe asks for sweet dark chocolate you may also use semi-sweet chocolate. Contains often 35-45% cocoa solids.
Semi-sweet chocolate
This is the classic dark baking chocolate which can be purchased in most grocery stores. It is frequently used for cakes, cookies and brownies. Can be used instead of sweet dark chocolate. It has a good, sweet flavour. Contains often 40-62% cocoa solids.
Bittersweet chocolate
A dark sweetened chocolate which must contain at least 35% cocoa solids. Good quality bittersweet chocolate usually contains 60% to 85% cocoa solids depending on brand. If the content of cocoa solids is high the content of sugar is low, giving a rich, intense and more or less bitter chocolate flavour. Bittersweet chocolate is often used for baking/cooking. If a recipe specifies bittersweet chocolate do not substitute with semi-sweet or sweet chocolate. Please ensure that you buy the correct type! European types of bittersweet chocolate usually contains very large amounts of cocoa solids, and some of them have quite bitter taste.
Unsweetened chocolate
A bitter chocolate which is only used for baking. The flavour is not good, so it is not suitable for eating. Use it only if a recipe specifies 'unsweetened chocolate'. It contains almost 100% cocoa solids, about half of it might be fat (cocoa butter).

Aim
To investigate if the amount of cocoa solids in chocolate effect its melting time.

Hypothesis
I think that the melting time of the chocolate will increase with increasing amounts of cocoa solids.

Variables
Independent variable: the amount of cocoa solids in the chocolate.
Dependent variable: the melting time of the chocolate.
Controlled variables: the size of the flame, the temperature of the water, the amount of water, the type of bowl, the amount of chocolate melted.

Materials/Equipment
  • 3 different types of chocolate that have different cocoa solid contents - in this case, I am using Cadbury Old Gold (70%), Club Original Dark Chocolate (45%) and Cadbury Dairy Milk (26%). I am using 100 grams of each chocolate. 
  • A small-medium sized saucepan
  • Three identical bowls/cups that will fit into the saucepan
  • Water
  • A thermometer
  • A stove
  • Matches
  • Measuring cup (that measures at least 1L)
  • Stop watch

Safety Precautions
In step 3: Do not hold onto the burning match for too long. Blow it out before it burns you.
In step 7: Be careful when placing the bowl into the water that you do not burn yourself.

Method
  1. Measure 600ml of water and pour it into the saucepan.
  2. Break off 100g of chocolate from each of the different chocolates and place each of  them into the three bowls.
  3. Light the match and hold it to the stove while turning on the gas. Safety: Do not hold onto the burning match for too long. Blow it out before it burns you.
  4. Adjust the flame to the highest possible and remember to keep the flame constant - always use the same one.
  5. Place the thermometer into the saucepan, then place the saucepan onto the flame.
  6. Wait for the water to come to a boil when the thermometer is 100 degrees on the thermometer.
  7. Place ONE of the bowls - make sure you know which one is which - into the boiling water. Safety: Be careful when placing the bowl into the water that you do not burn yourself.
  8. Time how long the chocolate takes to melt.
  9. Record the results down in a table.
  10. Wait for it to cool before taking the bowl of chocolate out of the saucepan. 
  11. Repeat steps 6-9 for the other two chocolates.
  12. Repeat this experiment two more times for reliability.
  13. Calculate the average for each chocolate and record the results in a table.

Results

Chocolate 
Amount of Cocoa Solids
Trial #1
Trial #2
Trial #3
Trial Averages
Cadbury Old Gold (100g)
70%
7 minutes 30 seconds
7 minutes 48 seconds
7 minutes 18 seconds
7 mins 32 sec
Club Original Dark Chocolate (100g)
45%
6 minutes 53 seconds
6 minutes 35 seconds
6 minutes 47 seconds
6 mins 45 sec
Cadbury Milk Chocolate (100g)
26%
6 minutes 23 seconds
6 minutes 10  seconds
6 minutes 40 seconds
6 mins 24 sec
pastedGraphic.pdfpastedGraphic_1.pdf
Discussion
In this experiment, the aim was to investigate if the amount of cocoa solids in chocolate has an effect on the time it takes to melt. The data collected suggested that the melting times of chocolate is dependent on the amount of cocoa solids in the chocolate. From the results of the experiment, it was noted that the melting times of the chocolates increased as the amounts of cocoa solids increased. The hypothesis that the melting times would increase due to increased amounts of cocoa solids was supported by this data. The data supporting this can be found at the links listed below in the bibliography. The results showed that the Cadbury Old Gold, which had the most cocoa solid content, was the chocolate that took the longest time to melt. Followed by Club Original Dark Chocolate, which had the second highest amount of cocoa solids. The fastest to melt was also the chocolate that had the least amount of cocoa solids, Cadbury Milk Chocolate with only 26% cocoa solids.  
The results of the experiment were very consistent, further supporting the hypothesis. This experiment fits the criteria in terms of reliability. Each type of chocolate was melted and the results recorded. This was then repeated two more times. This makes it reliable as instead of a single result, there are three results for each chocolate, allowing them to be averaged to produce a more valid result. The validity of this experiment is satisfactory, but not the best it could be. A weakness in the experiment is that after each boiling, the water was not refilled to 600ml. This is  a weakness because since the flame was on full strength, it is most likely that a notable amount of water would have evaporated into the air. It may help to refill the water to exactly 600ml after boiling the chocolate as some of the water may have evaporated into the air during the boiling. This will improve the validity and accuracy of the experiment. 
An adjustment to the experiment that may improve accuracy and reliability might be to test chocolates with a significant difference in their cocoa solid content. If there was a chance to redo the experiment again, using using chocolates such as milk chocolate (10%-12% cocoa solids), sweet dark chocolate (35%- 45% cocoa solids), semi sweet chocolate (40%- 62% cocoa solids) and bittersweet chocolate (almost 100% cocoa solids). The use of chocolates with a notable difference in cocoa solid content will improve accuracy as the result will show more clearly if the amount of cocoa solids actually has an effect on the melting time. 
As seen from the results, it can be said that the melting times of the chocolates is dependent on the amount of cocoa solids the chocolate possesses. This can be seen in the table as well as the graph. The graph clearly shows a decrease in the time it takes to melt as the amount of cocoa solids decreases. The Old Gold Cadbury Chocolate has a total cocoa solid content of 70% and was the one that took the longest to melt with an average time of 7 minutes and 32 seconds. Following Old Gold is Club Dark Chocolate with the second highest amount of cocoa solids, 45% with an average time of 6 minutes and 45 seconds. The chocolate that took the least time to melt was also the one that had the least amount of cocoa solids. With only 26% cocoa solids, Cadbury Dairy Milk Chocolate took 6 minutes and 24 seconds to melt. With these trials and averages, a distinctive pattern can be seen. The results are supported by the the data, which suggest that as the amount of cocoa solids increases, the melting time will increase. 
It can be said the results of the experiment correspond with the data collected. The results of the experiment therefore supported the data collected. This is important as without the data, the would be nothing to compare the results to. The data is there to verify the results and confirm what they indicate is true. The data indicated that the time it chocolate takes to melt is dependent on the of cocoa solid content. There were some issues dealing with validity that may have effected the credibility of the results.

Conclusion
For my experiment, I investigated if the amount of cocoa solids in the chocolate effects the melting times. From this experiment, it was found that the melting time of the chocolate increased as the amount of cocoa solids increased. The chocolate that took the longest time to melt was Cadbury Old Gold, with an average time of 7 minutes and 32 seconds. Old Gold also had the highest amount of cocoa solids, which was 70%. Coming last was Cadbury Dairy Milk with 6 minutes and 24 seconds. Cadbury Dairy Milk also had the least amount of cocoa solids.

Bibliography
Bolger, J.(1999-2011)Why Does Chocolate Melt? [internet]. United States. Available from:< http://www.ehow.com/about_5285486_chocolate-melt.html>[accessed28th March, 2011]
CacaoNet.(2003)Types of Chocolate [internet]. Place of publication unknown. Available from:< http://www.cacaoweb.net/chocolate.html>[accessed 28th March, 2011]
Edgar, B.(2002) Science Focus 9 [internet]. Place of publication not found. Publisher McGraw-Hill Ryerson School. Available from:<http://www.trinity.catholic.edu.au/home/sci_stu/sci/s4/y8/sf2/sf2_ch9.pdf>[accessed 8th March, 2011]
The Writing Center.(Year of publication unknown)Scientific Reports [internet]. University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. Available from:< http://www.unc.edu/depts/wcweb/handouts/lab_report_complete.html>[accessed ??]
Wikipedia Foundation Inc.(2011) Chocolate [internet]. Place of publication unknown. Available from:< http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chocolate>[accessed 28th March, 2011]
(last name unknown),M.(2003)Real Chocolate Bars [internet. Seattle, Washington. Available from:< http://www.xocoatl.org/bars.htm#ingred>[accessed 28th March, 2011]
I accessed the bubbl.us website many times, including on the 8th of March, 2011, and the 6th of April, 2011.
                                          

Sunday, 1 May 2011

Week 2

I have also graphed the results into a column graph to make it easier to compare the different chocolates and see the variations easier. Also, I have converted the seconds into decimals so it is easier to read.



Late Week 2 Bubbl.us

This is a mind map that I did on bubbl.us
The mind map answers questions that we were asked to consider in the guidelines.

I used the bubbl.us website, which is at
https://bubbl.us/
on the 6th of April.



Week 2 Progress Report

This is some background information I have found a few weeks ago, but did not add.



Types of Chocolate
White chocolate
Chocolate made with cocoa butter, sugar, milk, emulsifier, vanilla and sometimes other flavourings. It does not contain any non-fat ingredients from the cacao bean and has therefore an off-white colour. In some countries white chocolate cannot be called 'chocolate' because of the low content of cocoa solids. It has a mild and pleasant flavour and can be used to make Chocolate Mousse, Panna Cotta and other desserts.
Milk chocolate
Sweet chocolate which normally contains 10-20% cocoa solids (which includes cocoa and cocoa butter) and more than 12% milk solids. It is seldom used for baking, except for cookies.
Dark chocolate
Sweetened chocolate with high content of cocoa solids and no or very little milk, it may contain up to 12% milk solids. Dark chocolate can either be sweet, semi-sweet, bittersweet or unsweetened. If a recipe specifies 'dark chocolate' you should first try semi-sweet dark chocolate.
Sweet dark chocolate
Similar to semi-sweet chocolate, it is not always possible to distinguish between the flavour of sweet and semi-sweet chocolate. If a recipe asks for sweet dark chocolate you may also use semi-sweet chocolate. Contains often 35-45% cocoa solids.
Semi-sweet chocolate
This is the classic dark baking chocolate which can be purchased in most grocery stores. It is frequently used for cakes, cookies and brownies. Can be used instead of sweet dark chocolate. It has a good, sweet flavour. Contains often 40-62% cocoa solids.
Bittersweet chocolate
A dark sweetened chocolate which must contain at least 35% cocoa solids. Good quality bittersweet chocolate usually contains 60% to 85% cocoa solids depending on brand. If the content of cocoa solids is high the content of sugar is low, giving a rich, intense and more or less bitter chocolate flavour. Bittersweet chocolate is often used for baking/cooking. If a recipe specifies bittersweet chocolate do not substitute with semi-sweet or sweet chocolate. Please ensure that you buy the correct type! European types of bittersweet chocolate usually contains very large amounts of cocoa solids, and some of them have quite bitter taste.
Unsweetened chocolate
A bitter chocolate which is only used for baking. The flavour is not good, so it is not suitable for eating. Use it only if a recipe specifies 'unsweetened chocolate'. It contains almost 100% cocoa solids, about half of it might be fat (cocoa butter).
The website I visited to get this information can be found at